*I received this novel from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review*
Tumbledown Manor by Helen Brown is a meaty contemporary chick
lit novel. Yes, maybe I made up a genre just now. It’s not exactly what most
people would call “fluff”; a term I actually object to. The main character is about
a writer named Lisa, who is celebrating her 50th birthday when she
accidentally finds out her husband is cheating on her. So, considering she’s
originally from Australia, Lisa decides to take off and move back there to deal
with both the breakdown of her marriage and also writer’s block. The latter
part – the insight into her creative process – was my favourite part of the
whole novel. She is writing a trilogy of historical novels (with a heavy dose
of sexy romance) about the Bronte sisters, and Tumbledown Manor was also infused with random interesting tidbits
about their lives. Yes, there were hindsight diagnoses and assigning medical
conditions based on descriptions of people, but still, the writing process was
fun to read about.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEiloMEGhGD8-1JN5jMgSiRUd9zkxPglfOZwDYym9HiVmLb0KsKomb60sl5UKSU1o_mKuWJl0pl3Ti6ruDYcxjG1Or5cULNOctGWQf1-QxHc_8B7_l14-q85fckpjgZH1WRGQmyjzSf4inw/s200/manor.jpg)
The novel also
features a careful romance, it’s subtle and slow-burning with a couple of
tropey “simple misunderstandings”. Still, I could get on board with it, and I
liked she took her time getting over her 20+ year marriage. Oh, and there was
also a slight mystery, but it was completely in the background.
Now, there were some
aspects to the novel that I didn’t fully enjoy. Firstly, it featured a couple
of odd-sounding metaphors and similes. The text seemed to be completely
saturated with them to the point where it was difficult to actually understand
what the author was trying to say. It did get better as the novel progressed! Secondly,
the main character definitely did not act her age, in the sense that she was
really immature at times and even silly. She just plain wasn’t as intelligent
as I would expect a grown-ass woman to be. One of my pet peeves: she used an
odd abbreviated text speech with her daughter, which I find kind of unlikely
for a writer. I’ve met a few, and they all manage to type out most words, and
wouldn’t be caught saying “Gr8”. I know she was perhaps trying to relate to her
daughter but lady, use your words.
Also, I feel like the
novel was trying to handle too many “issues” at once. It just seemed A LOT for
one single person. The author did say she knows women (plural!) that these
things have happened to, so it felt really artificial piling them all on the
shoulders of this one lady. Even though the book outlined these possible
issues, they weren’t really dealt with. For instance, Lisa’s son was openly gay
and she accepted it as she should, but some other characters had weird issues
with Ted’s sexuality and they were never actually addressed or analysed. Sidenote:
I don’t think someone being gay is an issue. However, I took issue with the way
people refused to accept it. That homophobia wasn’t really addressed within the
family, which I find unrealistic. What is more, Lisa’s daughter Portia had a
suspected eating disorder and that again was almost ignored by most of her
family. Then there was a brief mention of cancer; of course also divorce,
disability, racism. It just felt a lot for one woman, unless she’s a character
on Grey’s Anatomy.
Thus, I am giving this
book 3,5 stars. I rounded it up to 4 on Goodreads, but I actually think I’m
right smack in the middle of “I liked it” and “I really liked it”. I know, this
makes no sense. Tumbledown Manor
wasn’t a spectacular literary masterpiece but it was fun to read, never a
trudge, and it helped in getting me out of a reading slump. Cozy, is how I
would describe it: I laughed out loud, I teared up. Also, I have gotten a bit
more into Australian fiction lately. The author is originally from New Zealand
so maybe Australasian fiction then :). If you like contemporaries or chick lit
(in the best possible sense of the word), then go for it!
"After a lifetime of enabling others, surely she'd earned the right to make her own choices, no matter how outlandish?"